post "I'm up for it" here only if you would like to receive some constructive criticism of your work.

I hope those who put their names on this list are also willing to OFFER critical feedback to others on the list. Emma has some thoughts on this which are discussed here.

if you want, you can include a link to a particular page in your blog, or leave that up to the critics.

If you would like to talk about critical feedback, please have that discussion in the other 'off topic' topic, constructive criticism.


oh, and I'm up for it.

:countmeinsmiley:

I'm up for it.

I'm up for it.

Yes, please.

Julia, I see you have added a little more to your original post. I am willing to give critical feedback to others, however sometimes I do not feel there is a need. I don't think I could possibly do it for every shot, just as I said, when the need arises I guess...

the conversation continues in the constructive criticism topic. If you're interested in giving and getting critique, add your name here.

"constructive criticism" is a stillbirth. in general, most of the stuff you can't pronounce without getting your tongue twisted is ideological bullshit.

i therefore don't want it on my blog, no thank you. rather just tell me what i post if fucked up, freakin' beautiful or plain nonsense... i get more kicks out of that then any well balanced "your right edge of the picture is slightly more shiny then your lower left corner" bla bla.

ignore the ranting lion above, and just post your names. kthanxbye

I'd love some criticism!

Yes, I'm up for it!

Why not. More to gain. I'm up for it.

After this question was raised, but before even adding my name to a list, it has seemed that lately a greater number of people have been stepping up to write more substantive, photo-specific comments about members' entries. Almost as if they remembered that that's a thing we can do here. It sure beats the hell out of 9 "great post" comments at the end of the page!

Yes please

Yes, I'm up for it!

Me please.

i'm up for it!

of course, i'm up for it!

Count me in

i'm up for it!