tough call. I think like the second one better, but I'm not sure if it's because of the bw or the crop. I like the way the lines of the boat and reflection point right at the corners of the frame in the second. They're both great shots.
Give me the colored one ! yes ! I was also thinking of the same thing with Angie, the sign in the bacground is the only thing that bothers me ans would have me choosing the b&w... but the color one is my choice :))